The last time we used the planer it seemed to be making a new noise on top of its usual cacophony. It seemed wise to investigate, so we started trying to narrow down where it was coming from.
Begin at the beginning

First things first, it’s a big 3 horsepower AC motor on the bottom, connected by a trio of belts to the top of the machine. A gearbox and transmission up there propels the drive rollers and the cutter head. The belts seem like an obvious potential problem area, so let’s check on them. Okay, they seem fine. Next step is to take them off and see if that makes the noise go away, in which case the noise is probably belt related or gearbox/transmission related. Hmmmm. I’d guess the noise isn’t as loud with the belts off, but it’s still present. I’m thinking this means it’s a motor issue, maybe a failing or failed bearing? Spinning the armature by hand it seems very solid. Unknown Pseudonym observed that the pulley sheave looked out of round, like maybe the shaft of the motor is bent and it’s taking a wobbly path as it rotates. Oh ugh. Alright, next step is to take the sheave off the motor and see what we’re looking at. The upper sheave appears to be keyed to the shaft it’s driving and held on with a bolt and washer concentric to the shaft, so presumably it’s the same setup below. Certainly there’s a bolt in the end of the armature, and it feels like the sheave has some slop on the shaft, so my guess is that it’s not a tapered fit.
Making it worse


Key the edge knocked off
I don’t know what the right way is to remove the bolt, the problem being that turning the bolt will just turn the armature of the motor. We settled on grabbing the circumference of the pulley with the biggest pair of channel lock pliers in the tool cabinet. This seemed like a pretty dumb way to go about it, but… yeah, I don’t know. The bolt came out for a few turns and then got a lot tighter. With the application of unreasonable force we managed to shear the head off the bolt, thus creating an additional problem to solve. However, we can now remove the sheave and see what’s going on. It looks like the key has had one of its edges knocked off, as has the keyway on the armature. Getting a replacement key is easy, fixing the keyway on the armature seems difficult.
Sealing its fate?

At this point it looks we’ve got at least two problems: first, the keyway is damaged on the motor, allowing the sheave to wobble around, further damaging the keyway, etc. Second, there’s bolt with a sheared off head stuck in the armature. One of those problems can be fixed right now, so let’s dig in. I’ve got a set of screw extractors for just this sort of problem. Step 1 is to drill a hole in the offending bolt, followed by hammering in the extractor, and then backing the bolt out by putting an adjustable wrench on the extractor and turning CCW (the extractor is reverse threaded). The adjustable wrench seems like a terrible idea, as the extractor itself is only perhaps 3/16″ in diameter, and the flats on the square tang are tiny. Sticking with the theme of applying unreasonable force, I used a drill to turn the extractor, while Unknown Pseudonym used a pair of vise grips to hold the shaft of the motor. I know what you’re thinking, “that will end up scoring the shaft of the motor” — wrong! It will end up breaking the screw extractor off in the bolt and scoring the shaft of the motor.
Coda
So we’ve managed to go from a planer that was functional, albeit making a new strange noise and probably headed to failing, to one that is completely nonfunctional and may require a new motor to get it running again. I can’t help but feeling this could have somehow been avoided.


